Voters who gave Democrats control of Arizona’s Legislature for the first time in 60 years told LOOKOUT they want real change. Democratic leaders are promising to be “thoughtful and intentional.”
After a report from LOOKOUT and The Intercept, the town wants a written explanation for why an audit certified in 2023 listed no allegations of sexual misconduct, even though state corrections records list three.
Arizona Voters Say They Want Democrats to Go Big. But Will They?
Voters who gave Democrats control of Arizona’s Legislature for the first time in 60 years told LOOKOUT they want real change. Democratic leaders are promising to be “thoughtful and intentional.”
Arizona Democratic party supporters walk to the exit after attending a watch party on election night Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024, in Phoenix. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin, File)
Arizona voters handed Democrats the governor’s office and both chambers of the Legislature in the Nov. 3 election, giving the party trifecta control of state government for the first time in 60 years. But their strategy for how they wield that power is still up in the air — and it’s unclear how voters will accept their style of governance.
In the week after the election, LOOKOUT spoke to a dozen voters who voted for Democrats who said they want to see lawmakers use their newfound power aggressively. Even those who urged a slower pace said they want to see significant change.
But in interviews with LOOKOUT, incoming leaders and other Democratic lawmakers have been far less specific about what they plan to do. They said they heard voters’ message, and they pointed to affordability and a backlog of bills Republicans refused to hear for years. But few would commit to concrete examples of legislation or a timeline, and the House’s new majority whip said it was still too early to say how fast Democrats would move.
Even on LGBTQ+ rights, where lawmakers came closest to naming concrete goals, they came wrapped in promises to research, convene stakeholders and not “get ahead of ourselves.”
“We understand the clear message voters sent,” said Rep. Brian Garcia, D-Tempe, the new House majority whip. Voters “want action, they want to see us deliver immediate support and relief."
Incoming House Speaker Oscar De Los Santos, D-Phoenix, said during a speech on election night that Democrats won their new power “by kicking Turning Point’s ass.” The next day, he wrote on X: “Something going under-appreciated is AZ House & Senate Dems’ absolute laser focus and message discipline on An Arizona We Can Afford.”
But De Los Santos has also said Democrats won’t use the majority the way Republicans did: In a September debate, he said Democrats wouldn’t bottle up Republican bills — the tactic Republicans used for years to keep Democratic proposals from getting a hearing.
“I don’t believe that is a good way to operate,” De Los Santos said. “I don’t think that’s how Democrats should operate when we’re in the majority.”
LOOKOUT attempted to reach De Los Santos’ office multiple times for comment.
That leaves the question of what Democrats will do with their power, and whether they will stick with the cautious politics that defined the party during decades in the minority or start playing the game the way state Republicans have — allowing them to keep a stranglehold on power for over half a century.
The general sense among Democratic voters LOOKOUT spoke to was excitement, and an expectation of real change.
“I’m hyped,” said Tucson-based Oscar Chavira, 30. “We’re not at a point where we can afford to play the middle ground,” he said. “We have to be aggressive.” He said he hoped to “see actual change” on abortion rights and scaling back immigration enforcement, urging Democratic lawmakers “not to be intimidated.”
Another Tucson resident, Celia Rodriguez, a westside barber, also said she wants a transformative agenda: “Actions are stronger than words,” she said. “We don’t need messaging, we need actual change.”
Karl Johnson, 72, went further. “I want everything to change,” he said. “Strip Republicans of all control.”
But other Democratic voters said they want change at a slower pace.
Hunter, who was waiting for a drink outside a Tucson coffee shop, said the changes should come “in a way that’s sustainable.” Kate, another Democratic voter, said she was “thrilled” with the results and urged a “tempered approach” to governing the state. Still, she added, “If they wanted to do something a little more humanitarian, that would be good.” (Both Hunter and Kate requested only their first names be used due to nerves around political volatility.)
Democratic leaders said they got the message. But when pressed on what that means in practice, most of their answers centered on priorities and process rather than firm commitments.
“We understand the clear message voters sent,” said Rep. Brian Garcia, D-Tempe, the new House majority whip. Voters “want action, they want to see us deliver immediate support and relief,” he said.
But Garcia said it is still “a little too early to tell how the pace and cadence [of that action] will shape out.”
Garcia, a co-chair of the Legislature’s LGBTQ+ caucus, said he has received numerous emails and messages from transgender people and their families since voters passed Proposition 318, the ballot measure that limits how transgender youth can participate in school and club sports and which locker rooms they can use.
“They’re scared and want us to take action,” he said. But Garcia said Democrats “don’t want to get ahead of ourselves.” Instead, he said, lawmakers are “convening partners to understand their perspectives and approaches and recommendations. We want to be thoughtful and intentional.” He said Democrats will work with the appropriate caucuses and study the issue before announcing any action.
On same-sex marriage, there is currently a constitutional and legislative ban on the practice. That means if Obergefell v. Hodges, the 2015 U.S. Supreme Court decision guaranteeing the right to same-sex marriage, were overturned, marriage rights in Arizona would be at risk. Because the ban is in the constitution, it would be difficult to undo at the Capitol.
Garcia has sponsored bills in the last two sessions to guarantee marriage equality. Democratic legislators could send the question to voters, now, as a ballot referral.
“It’s not like voters elected Democrats to do nothing. They elected them to get shit done.”
On immigration, Garcia, the son of immigrant parents, said there is a lot the state can do locally, but he again said he did not want to get ahead of the caucus.
Priya Sundareshan, the new Senate majority leader, said much of the early work will be clearing a backlog: “We’re not going to refuse to hear Republican bills, but there are hundreds of bills that have been languishing for years, this backlog needs to be worked through,” she said.
Sundareshan said she isn’t looking to change the Senate’s rules and procedures right away, though the chamber may revisit them after a year or so. She acknowledged that the rulebook has been changed over time to concentrate power in the hands of the majority, which Democrats now hold.
On immigration, Sundareshan said Democrats are weighing the limits of state authority against federal authority. “How do we protect our rights and freedoms from federal overreach and how do we make sure that detention facilities are complying with basic human rights issues, with health and safety regulations?”
Incoming Senate Majority Whip Analise Ortiz, D-Phoenix, offered some of the most specific answers. “We want to make life more affordable for people,” she told LOOKOUT. “We have introduced bills year after year that were just put in a drawer and never saw the light of day. We’re finally able to move those forward.”
She pointed to the Stop Corporate Homebuyers Act, which would limit the number of homes corporations can buy, and to Arizona’s Empowerment Scholarship Account program, the billion-dollar program that gives parents public money to pay for private or religious education. “The ESA program is completely unsustainable,” Ortiz said. Democrats are looking at an income cap “so that the wealthiest 1% cannot benefit” from the program, she said, though she added that Democrats don’t yet have an exact idea of what reforms are needed.
“I’m devastated that 318 passed,” Ortiz said. “Trans kids need to be protected.” She said a statewide nondiscrimination law is her first priority. Such bills have been written and introduced in the past but never made it past committee under Republican control. “When it comes down to everyday lives of LGBTQ+ Arizonans, we’re seeing discrimination in housing, employment and other issues have a real impact on people,” Ortiz said. “No matter what city you live in, you should be protected.”
Ortiz said Democratic lawmakers need to sit down with students and activists to make sure transgender Arizonans are protected now that Prop 318 has passed.
Ortiz also wants a full repeal of SB 1070, the 2010 anti-immigrant law that sparked protests across the state and was later partly struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court. Repealing it has long been a Democratic goal. “There are still parts of that law on the books enabling cities to collaborate with ICE to rip families apart, and that needs to stop,” she said, adding that there is “likely an appetite” in Arizona for a law like New Mexico’s, which prohibits local jurisdictions from entering into contracts with ICE for immigrant detention, and that the Latino Caucus would take up the issue.
Above all, Ortiz said, Democrats need to keep their majority. “We need to deliver results for people to feel in their pocketbooks,” she said. “When Democrats are elected, we deliver for working-class people.” She said it was critical to “actually make life more affordable for people” and be able to tell voters by the next election: “Look what we delivered.”
Rep. Betty Villegas, D-Tucson, said her top priorities are education, health and housing affordability. “We can start with trying to keep people housed,” she told LOOKOUT. She said Democrats need to strengthen the state’s landlord-tenant law to “make it a little more of a level playing field” between landlords and renters, adding that current law is “landlord favored.”
“We have so many bills that never got hearings,” Villegas said. She said she is looking forward to Democratic-led committees that would actually send Democratic bills to the governor’s desk, and she wants housing bills that save money for families, not just developers. “Affordability is as important for someone buying as it is for those building the house,” she said. “We should pay attention not only to what it costs to build, but what it costs a family to live in a house.”
On immigration, Villegas said she supports abolishing ICE, but until that happens, Democrats have to work with what they have. “We already have bills aligned to focus on what other states have done to control ICE from coming into private property,” she said. Last month, Border Patrol agents entered private property without a warrant to arrest land defenders protesting border wall construction in Lochiel.
Arizona isn’t the first state where newly empowered Democrats have had to decide how far to go. Travis Edgar, the founder of Federal Limits, a nonpartisan watchdog group that tracks federal law enforcement’s influence and overreach in local politics, told LOOKOUT that other states offer a guide.
“The clearest preview may be Virginia, where Democrats took full control in January. Gov. Abigail Spanberger ended 287(g) agreements at state agencies and signed a ban on officers hiding their faces, but vetoed a bill restricting immigration arrests at courthouses and schools,” Edgar said.
A federal judge has since blocked Virginia’s mask ban for federal agents, along with most of a new law limiting local police partnerships with federal immigration enforcement. Both rulings are on appeal.
A spokesperson for Gov. Katie Hobbs said the governor is not ready to comment on next session’s legislative agenda.
Want to Share Insider Information?
Help keep power accountable.
LOOKOUT relies on tips from readers to get our news out. Click on the button below to submit a secure email to our team. Any information you send will be kept confidential in accordance with our ethics guidelines.
Jeanne Woodbury, a lobbyist with Creosote Partners, said Hobbs’ vetoes have reflected the bills Republicans sent her, and that a Democratic majority will send her bills she has no reason to veto. Many of them are already written. “There’s a lot we can do around LGBTQ+ rights,” Woodbury told LOOKOUT. “There are really practical things like helping LGBTQ+ people access identity documents, birth certificates, vital records and name changes.”
“Marriage equality I think is one we can finally fix,” Woodbury said.
She said there are voices pushing legislators to play it safe: pass a handful of good bills and don’t rock the boat: “It’s not like voters elected Democrats to do nothing,” Woodbury said. “They elected them to get shit done.”
Before you go...
At LOOKOUT, we believe in the power of
community-supported journalism. You're at the heart of that community, and your support helps us deliver the
news and information the LGBTQ+ community needs to thrive.
After a report from LOOKOUT and The Intercept, the town wants a written explanation for why an audit certified in 2023 listed no allegations of sexual misconduct, even though state corrections records list three.
Voters approved Proposition 134, barring trans students from teams that match their gender identity. Jeffco Public Schools says it will comply, though Democratic lawmakers could still change the law.
Over five months of conversations, a trans Phoenician, a rural New Mexico progressive, a conservative Colorado dad, a Utah labor organizer and a disillusioned Nevada independent found more common ground than the partisan noise suggests
LOOKOUT Publications (EIN: 92-3129757) is a federally recognized nonprofit news outlet.
All mailed inquiries can be sent to 221 E. Indianola Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85012.